Looking Beyond the League Table
Following our successful promotion campaign, attention has naturally started to turn towards the challenge of building a squad capable of competing at a higher level, although before making decisions about recruitment and departures, Mateusz Wrona wanted to understand exactly what he already had at his disposal. Promotion has been achieved through a collective effort, with several players producing outstanding seasons, but the club cannot afford to make decisions based purely on reputation, age or a handful of impressive performances. With a limited budget and the likelihood of increased demands next season, understanding the relationship between a player’s contribution and the cost of employing them is going to be an important part of our planning.
To help with this process, we sent our Football Manager save file to FM Stag, who ran the squad data through the FM Stag Player Value Index. The purpose of the exercise was to establish which players were providing the greatest return relative to their wages, while also accounting for factors such as age and leadership. The results give us a fascinating insight into the financial hierarchy within the dressing room, and, perhaps more importantly, they challenge a few assumptions about which players are genuinely providing the best value for Ruch Chorzów.
The analysis covered 21 players who had accumulated more than 300 minutes during the period from 27 June 2026 to 30 May 2027, with a combined weekly wage bill of £19,735. The calculation takes into account the total cost of each player’s wages over the 48.14-week period, before comparing that cost against their weighted contribution to the team’s performances. Contribution is not simply measured by average rating, as the model raises a player’s rating to the power of 1.2 and multiplies it by their minutes played, creating a weighted contribution figure which is then compared with the rest of the squad. The model also applies adjustments for age and leadership, before producing a final Value Index in which a higher number represents better value relative to the player’s cost.
It is important to understand that this is not a definitive judgement on a player’s ability or their importance to the team, because the index does not account for every element of footballing performance, including injuries, tactical suitability, recent form or external transfer-market value. Instead, it provides another piece of evidence for Wrona and the recruitment team to use when considering contracts, squad roles and potential transfers, with the intention of making sure that our wage structure remains sustainable as the club moves into a more demanding division.
The Best Value: The Foundation of Our Promotion Campaign

The most striking result in the entire analysis belongs to 18-year-old Mateusz Rosół, whose Value Index of 7.10 places him comfortably above every other player included in the study. His numbers are remarkable when you consider that he played 3,085 minutes, recorded an average rating of 7.15 and earned just £240 per week, meaning that he delivered an enormous amount of football for a very small proportion of the club’s wage budget. His age also provides a significant benefit within the index, while his leadership attribute of 12 adds further value to his overall score, making him the clearest example of the type of player Ruch must continue to develop and protect. For Wrona, Rosół represents more than an excellent statistical return, because he is already demonstrating that a young player from within the club’s environment can become a major contributor to a promotion-winning side without placing unnecessary pressure on the finances.
Andrej Lukić is the next name on the list, recording a Value Index of 2.44 after playing 3,118 minutes and achieving an average rating of 7.15 on a weekly wage of £900. At 33 years old, he does not receive the same age benefit as Rosół, but his combination of consistent availability, strong performances and relatively modest wages still makes him one of the most valuable players in the squad. His leadership attribute of 14 also contributes positively to the calculation, and his experience has been important in providing stability at the back throughout the season. Although his age means that we will eventually need to plan for a successor, there is little reason to consider moving him on simply because he is approaching the latter stages of his career, particularly when his performances and value to the dressing room remain so strong.
Szymon Szymański completes the top three with an index of 1.69, having accumulated 2,477 minutes and an average rating of 7.09 on £1,000 per week. He has been another dependable presence, offering the consistency that a promotion-chasing side needs across a long campaign, while Denis Ventúra and Agustín Coscia both register an index of 1.58. Ventúra’s 2,675 minutes and Coscia’s 2,575 minutes demonstrate how regularly both players have been involved, with Coscia’s contribution particularly important given his role in leading the attack and providing goals throughout the season. Martin Konczkowski, Abraham Del Moral, Jakub Wrąbel, Krystian Wachowiak and Kacper Laskowski complete the remainder of the best-value group, with each player recording an index between 1.43 and 1.48.
What stands out across this group is the presence of players who have combined regular minutes with strong average ratings, while keeping their wages at a level that is proportionate to their contribution. This is exactly the type of squad structure we want to preserve as we move forward, because a team cannot build long-term success if every improvement on the pitch requires a significant increase in the wage bill. Rosół is the exceptional example, but the wider group demonstrates that we have a reliable core of players who have delivered consistent performances without becoming an excessive financial burden.
Roughly Fair Value: Good Contributions, but Room for Improvement

The next group contains five players whose Value Index figures sit closer to the middle of the distribution, suggesting that their output and wages are in a more balanced relationship once the model’s age and leadership adjustments have been applied. Shuma Nagamatsu leads this group with an index of 1.16, having produced an average rating of 7.19 across 1,612 minutes while earning £675 per week. His performances have been useful, and although his minutes are lower than some of the regular starters, the financial commitment required to retain him remains relatively modest. Michał Chrapek follows with an index of 1.06, reflecting his 2,089 minutes and average rating of 6.98, although at 35 years old the club will need to consider how much longer he can maintain his current level and whether his role should gradually change as younger players develop.
Cezary Demianiuk is perhaps the most interesting player in this section, especially when we consider that he only arrived during the winter window. Despite being 34 years old, he has already recorded an average rating of 7.40 across 1,344 minutes, while earning £575 per week and producing a Value Index of 1.02. His leadership attribute of 14 helps offset the age adjustment, and his performances suggest that Wrona and the recruitment team were justified in identifying him as an affordable option who could immediately improve the creativity and quality available in the wide attacking positions. His limited time at the club has not prevented him from making an impact, and the numbers reinforce the idea that experienced players can still represent sensible recruitment when their wages and expected roles are carefully managed.
Jakub Bielecki and Filip Wójcik sit just below parity with indexes of 0.92 and 0.79 respectively, although neither figure should automatically be interpreted as a reason to move either player on. Bielecki has contributed 1,320 minutes with an average rating of 7.13, while Wójcik has played 1,294 minutes and recorded a rating of 6.78. Their figures suggest that their wages are slightly ahead of their weighted contribution under this particular model, but both remain useful squad options, and their future value will depend on whether they can secure more consistent involvement and improve their performances in the higher division.
The Financial Pressure Points: Where Decisions Must Be Made

The final group is where the recruitment team will need to look most carefully, as these are the players whose wage commitments are currently producing the lowest return relative to their weighted contribution. Daniel Szczepan records the lowest Value Index in the entire squad at 0.35, having played 916 minutes and achieved an average rating of 6.78 while earning £1,100 per week. His cost per minute of £57.81 is particularly high when compared with players who have played considerably more football, and with his contract due to expire on 30 June 2027, the club has an opportunity to reconsider whether a renewal is financially sensible. At 31 years old, he is unlikely to be viewed as a long-term development investment, so unless Wrona believes he has an important role to play next season, allowing his contract to expire may be the most practical outcome.
Jakub Křištan and Patryk Sikora also fall into this category, with indexes of 0.36 and 0.42 respectively. Křištan has played only 747 minutes, recording an average rating of 6.82 on £900 per week, while Sikora has accumulated 908 minutes with a rating of 6.76 on £1,000 per week. Both players have struggled to establish themselves as regular contributors, and the numbers suggest that the club is paying a relatively high price for limited involvement. Sikora’s contract also expires at the end of June 2027, meaning that a decision will have to be made soon, while Křištan’s future should be assessed against the possibility of a loan move that could provide the regular football he has not been able to secure in Chorzów.
Patryk Szwedzik completes the group of players with contracts expiring this summer, recording an index of 0.48 after playing 1,060 minutes and achieving an average rating of 6.73 on £1,100 per week. Although he has played more than Křištan and Sikora, his overall contribution has not justified his current position in the wage structure according to the index, and his contract situation gives us a natural opportunity to reassess his place in the squad. The decision should not be based on the index alone, because his tactical role, age and potential usefulness as a rotation option still matter, but he will need to demonstrate that he can contribute more consistently if he is to remain part of Wrona’s plans.
Maciej Domański is a slightly different case, because his average rating of 7.32 is one of the strongest in the entire squad, yet his Value Index is only 0.61. At 36 years old, earning £1,400 per week and having played 1,455 minutes, his cost per minute stands at £46.32, making him one of the more expensive players relative to his involvement. His rating shows that he has performed well when selected, and it would be unfair to suggest that he has been a poor signing, particularly given the creativity he has brought since arriving in January. However, the figures do raise a legitimate question about whether the club should continue to carry that level of wage commitment for a player who is unlikely to offer a long-term solution. A reduced role, a shorter contract or a renegotiated wage would be more sensible considerations than simply ignoring the financial implications of his age and minutes played.
The final name in this group is Nikodem Leśniak-Paduch, whose index of 0.61 is influenced by his 768 minutes, average rating of 6.86 and weekly wage of £420. Unlike the older players in this section, he is only 21 years old, which makes his situation much more straightforward from a development perspective. There is still time for him to improve, but he needs regular football if he is going to turn his potential into consistent first-team contribution. A loan move to a club where he can play regularly would be a logical option, allowing us to retain control of his future while giving him the opportunity to develop away from the immediate pressure of a newly promoted side.
What Should We Do Next?
The most important conclusion from the analysis is that we do not need to rebuild the entire squad simply because we are moving into a higher division. We have a group of players who have demonstrated that they can deliver consistent performances while remaining relatively affordable, and that core should form the starting point for our next recruitment cycle. Rosół, Lukić, Szymański, Ventúra, Coscia, Konczkowski, Del Moral, Wrąbel, Wachowiak and Laskowski all appear in the best-value group, giving Wrona a strong foundation to work from. Some of these players will need competition or eventual succession planning, particularly the older members of the squad, but their current performances and financial returns suggest that they should not be discarded without a very good reason.
The priority should instead be to improve the areas where the current squad is either lacking quality or carrying too much financial weight for the contribution being received. The four players whose contracts expire on 30 June 2027 — Szczepan, Křištan, Sikora and Szwedzik — will be among the first decisions to resolve. Szczepan’s age, minutes and index make him a candidate to leave, while Sikora and Szwedzik will need to convince the coaching staff that they can offer more than they have managed this season. Křištan’s situation is more suited to a loan or a final opportunity to establish himself, particularly because he is still only 24 and could benefit from playing regularly elsewhere. The club should avoid offering new contracts simply to preserve squad numbers, because every renewal needs to make sense within the financial structure we are trying to build.
Domański requires a more considered decision. His rating of 7.32 demonstrates that he can still influence matches, and his contribution during the second half of the season has helped justify the decision to bring him to the club. However, his age and wage mean that a long-term commitment would carry unnecessary risk, especially with the demands of the Ekstraklasa likely to require greater athleticism and intensity across the squad. If he is prepared to accept a reduced wage and a clearly defined rotation role, there may still be value in keeping his experience and creativity available, but the club should not allow a strong average rating to distract from the wider financial picture.
For the younger players, the approach should be focused on development rather than immediate exits. Rosół is the clearest example of the value that can be created through giving young players meaningful opportunities, and we should be looking to replicate that pathway wherever possible. Leśniak-Paduch and Křištan need to be assessed in terms of how much football they can realistically receive next season, while the recruitment team should continue to identify opportunities to strengthen the squad without blocking the progression of our most promising players. The newly promoted status of the club will make it tempting to bring in a large number of experienced players, but doing so at the expense of our younger talent would undermine one of the most important foundations of the project.
Ultimately, the Player Value Index has given us a much clearer picture of where our money is being spent and which players are returning the greatest contribution for their wages. It has confirmed that we have some outstanding value within the squad, highlighted a handful of contracts that need careful attention, and provided a more objective starting point for discussions about potential departures. It has also reinforced an important principle for Wrona: recruitment is not simply about signing better players, but about signing the right players at the right cost, while making sure that the existing squad is being used as effectively as possible.
Promotion has given Ruch Chorzów the opportunity to take the next step, but the challenge now is to make sure that success is sustainable. We cannot afford to build a squad that is financially stretched after one good season, and we cannot allow sentiment to dictate decisions that should be based on performance, value and the long-term direction of the club. The numbers are not the final answer, but they give us a much stronger starting point for the conversations that will shape the summer.

Leave a Reply